ReShonda Tate Billingsley called me out on
my blog when I implied I might not get all of the featured books read prior to the Faith and Fiction Retreat.
After I picked myself up, wondering how ReShonda found
my blog (Google alerts, I'm sure), I responded and then vowed to read her book,
The Pastor's Wife. In full.


I did. And to my surprise, I loved it!
We teased each other about this cyber-encounter throughout the retreat.
The night of her featured book discussion, I confessed why I thought her book might be the one I didn't read and why I was surprised that I enjoyed it.
Because I wasn't looking forward to reading it.
What?Yes, I said it and
yes, I confessed.


The reason I felt the way I did goes back to the first book of Ms. Billingsley's that I read,
My Brother's Keeper, which was her debut novel. I read it after she'd already had several other titles published. I'd heard of her as a Christian fiction author so I brought my expectations for Christian fiction to that book. Except when I read it, the book was
definitely not Christian fiction.
This soured my taste for ReShonda's books.
In case you don't know, there's an ongoing debate about what constitutes Christian fiction. There are books published by the Christian Booksellers Association, which must adhere to very strict, conservative guidelines. However, there are books published by other publishers which don't meet these guidelines yet are still very much Christian fiction, because they have a Biblical basis and adhere to common albeit it less restrictive standards. Then there are books--a growing number, some might say--that are masquerading as Christian fiction. They throw in a church scene, a pastor, or God's name but beyond that they don't appear to be Christian fiction, based on things what the characters believe and how they behave. I'm not talking what some are calling "edgy" Christian fiction, yet another faction, which deals with raw topics like abortion, domestic violence, sexual abuse, etc. I'm talking about the books where you can tell that just enough stuff was thrown in to make unsuspecting readers think they're Christian fiction, where there's no spiritual journey nor any mention of Christ's grace or redemption.
So when I discovered one of ReShonda's books would be featured, I planned to read it last, if at all. I even considered not attending her session. I wasn't going to say anything against her works but I also wasn't necessarily going to support. Her writing was good. It just wasn't the Christian fiction it purported to be, in my eyes.
Now you know I read
all kinds of stuff and enjoy it. But books need to be what they claim to be, especially when it comes to Christian fiction. Don't tell me it is one thing when it's obviously another. I don't like false advertising.
Turns out it was all a bit misunderstanding--and a bit of mistaken judgment on my part.
ReShonda initially self-published
My Brother's Keeper, which she never intended to be categorized as Christian fiction. Except that's how readers and booklists began to label it. A mainstream publisher picked her up and reprinted that first book. But first they removed
all the references to God stuff. If it wasn't Christian fiction before the publisher got its hands on it, the story definitely wasn't afterwards.
About two years ago, I read
the re-released, sanitized version of
My Brother's Keeper. So I based my impression on a version that wasn't
the author's vision. Of course, I didn't
know the backstory. And although not originally released as a Christian fiction author, ReShonda is very much considered to be one now. So I put two and two together and came up with five.
In fact, the whole time I was reading that first book, I kept thinking that I'd read it before, some years ago, but that it had been a bit different, which made me wonder even more.
After reading and enjoying
The Pastor's Wife then, hearing the backstory, I felt so badly that I'd been so judgmental that I had to confess to ReShonda, and everyone else who was listening. We'd had an earlier discussion over what made Christian vs. inspirational fiction, about reader expectations, and about whether these authors had even set out to write Christian fiction, which ReShonda stated she had not. (Neither had Victoria Christopher Murray.)
ReShonda calls her later books, which are definitely Christian fiction, "Christian Friction". It fits.
My eyes and heart were opened and we shared a good laugh.
What readers get may not be what the author intended. That just never occurred to me before hearing this story. A different title, maybe. But wholesale changes?
There are some things an author does not control. Now, I still believe most publishers won't sanitize their authors work, and I by no means intend to malign the publisher. Publishing is a business and the publisher, having purchased the product, packaged it in the way most likely to engender sales. It happens.
Other things happen too.
Kristin Nelson recently told of an author who, when looking at their author copies, discovered that the first draft of the ARC was printed rather than the final copy. In addition to that, there were two uncorrected errors on the acknowledgement page. The publisher has scrapped the first print run, a costly error. But what if the author hadn't looked closely at her author copies and they'd made it into the hands of readers? How many readers would blame the publisher? How many the author, maybe believing that the authors writing wasn't up to snuff?
So my "one-and-done" rule has flown out the window. If I read an author and don't like the book, I won't assume I won't like the rest of their works. I'll remember that there may be an underlying story that I'll never know. That maybe something unforeseen happened during the publishing process. And I'll always thinks of ReShonda Tate Billingsley, a warm and funny personality you just have to encounter to fully comprehend and appreciate. I enjoyed her immensely.
Have you ever hated the first book you read by an author? Did you give the author a second try?
Peace & Blessings,
Patricia
Stay focused. Move Forward. Believe.
Peace & Blessings,
Patricia
Stay focused. Be deliberate. Believe.