Christian author Eric Wilson recently posted a missive entitled, "
Is It Time for Christian Fiction to Die?" In it, he questions what he perceives to be the narrowing of the guidelines within Christian publishing and perhaps what Christian readers find acceptable. He wonders where is the relevant Christian fiction that deals with real people who have real issues and real struggles with their faith.
Good questions.
I am the most unlikely proponent of Christian publishing because I too have issues with much of what is published. However, I have to say that I actually have found the opposite trend to be true. Yes, the Christian Booksellers Association (CBA) and seeming arbiter of all things Christian fiction is a very conservative group. Thus, the publishers hold to very conservative publishing guidelines. This is why many African-American Christian fiction authors--I said "many", not all--are published outside of the CBA, by mainstream publishers.
Still, I can site example after example of books that blew my mind because (1) they dealt with real issues and (2) they were published by CBA publishers. I've found this to be increasingly so in recent years. Here are a few:
The Shades of Style series (
Pink,
Jade,
Tangerine, and
Turquoise) and more recently, the Rhythms of Grace series (
Rhythms of Grace and
Songs of Deliverance) by Marilynn Griffith (Revell)
Anything by author Claudia Mair Burney, which is never for the faint of heart or spiritually timid, including my favorite Amanda Bell romantic suspense series (
Murder, Mayhem and a Fine Man;
Death, Deceit and Some Smooth Jazz; and
Deadly Charm) and the Christy award finalist,
Zora and Nicky. The Bell series was published by Howard Books, a CBA publisher, which now belongs to Simon and Schuster. (A number of CBA publishers have been gobbled up by mainstream publishers in the last few years.)
BTW, both Marilynn and Claudia are AA authors.
Walking on Broken Glass by Christa Allen (Abingdon Press), about recovering from alcoholism
Imaginary Jesus by Matt Mikalatos (Barna Books). Imagine, well, imagining Jesus. Everywhere. And being chased by Him. Literally...
The Atonement Child or
Redeeming Love by Francine Rivers (Tyndale). Rape, prostitution...does she know anything about safe Christianity?
Crossing Oceans by Gina Holmes (Tyndale). Death and surviving children. What will the dying mother do for her child?
The Six-Liter Club by Dr. Harry Kraus (Howard Books). Interracial dating and domestic abuse.
Chasing Lilacs by Carla Stewart (Faithwords). Mental illness and widowhood.
Back On Murder by J. Mark Bertrand (Bethany House) Homicide.
The Bishop by Steven James (Revell). Serial killers and single parenting.
I read most of these this year. I could go and on. What's not "real" about this stuff?
I'm not into speculative/fantasy fiction but there's a branch of that within Christian fiction. I believe there have even been recent titles picking up on the paranormal trend and involving vampires. Not quite what one expects from the CBA.
But let me not lead you to believe that I disagree with Eric wholeheartedly. I don't. On many levels, he's right. The CBA guidelines are strict and largely conservative. Writers conform or risk not being published by the CBA, but they understand that, and the CBA is certainly entitled to define the parameters of what they are willing to publish.
On the other hand, writers who write Christian fiction outside the CBA guidelines are, at times, looked down upon with Christian circles. Or, it seems so to me.
Subject matter and plot points that tend to be off limits within the CBA include divorce, dancing, gambling, smoking, cussing, out-of-wedlock pregnancy, sex before marriage and so much more. I get why they do this. There is a large number of Christian readers who seek fiction that upholds their faith. To the letter.
But there is also a large number who seek fiction that challenges them in their faith, that causes them to think differently about Christ and pushes them toward becoming a better Christian. I hate the term "edgy" which is often applied to this type of Christian fiction because it implies at the edge of or outside of the box.
I believe that Christianity has but
one boundary--belief in Christ as the Savior--and that the space within that boundary is big enough for us all. Give space to writers to use their God-given talent to shine a light on Him however He leads them to do so.
Do you read Christian fiction? Have you read any that might be deemed "edgy" of late? What do you think about CBA-published Christian fiction?
Peace & Blessings,
Patricia
Stay focused. Be deliberate. Believe.